Path: not-for-mail From: tomyee3@gmail.com (ProkaryoticCaspaseHomolog) Newsgroups: sci.physics.relativity Subject: Re: Oh my God! Date: Thu, 3 Oct 2024 08:00:22 +0000 Organization: novaBBS Message-Id: <5425df17b032f1c412c1a5ba4de9e803@www.novabbs.com> References: <38a724f9aa7028dc455f71fda36abdb8@www.novabbs.com> <1ea43eb5545f362bbcdb802e857bb126@www.novabbs.com> <6867f373a4258380db55b48d0a440d90@www.novabbs.com> <8c3912f32d9e1ad8f69c00cf2febffc8@www.novabbs.com> <4fd70cf6f71273c4d46907ff286919c1@www.novabbs.com> Mime-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: multipart/mixed;boundary="------------66fe4f151f6313.13136692" Injection-Info: i2pn2.org; logging-data="358537"; mail-complaints-to="usenet@i2pn2.org"; posting-account="Ooch2ht+q3xfrepY75FKkEEx2SPWDQTvfft66HacveI"; User-Agent: Rocksolid Light X-Rslight-Posting-User: 504a4e36a1e6a0679da537f565a179f60d7acbd8 X-Rslight-Site: $2y$10$MzAbNyVAOCIXprb0ZHcDYevepmKTd9jnGK1xdE.dEQw4qYx/KBSTW X-Spam-Checker-Version: SpamAssassin 4.0.0 This is a multi-part message in MIME format. --------------66fe4f151f6313.13136692 Content-Type: text/plain; charset=utf-8 Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit On Thu, 3 Oct 2024 3:04:17 +0000, gharnagel wrote: > On Wed, 2 Oct 2024 22:26:50 +0000, ProkaryoticCaspaseHomolog wrote: >> No. We are NOT obligated always to make ourselves the stationary >> observer. > > By the first principle, we are by necessity, "We" are always > stationary. We can have other observers in the lab but "We" > aren't there. You have put "Us" in three different frames. > > As to showing the order of events, all those dots are extreme > overkill. See attached figure 3. The dots represent spacetime events in S', mapped onto S using the inverse Lorentz transformation. In the left panel, the immediate context of the receiving event includes events 1, 2 and 6. If, to prevent the formation of causality loops, you apply your speed limit to superluminal velocities, the immediate context of the receiving event is shifted to include events 4, 5 and 8. The context of the receiving event shifts for EVERY observer moving at a different speed relative to S'. This is absurd. --------------66fe4f151f6313.13136692 Content-Type: image/png; name=Figure_3.png Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64 Content-Disposition: attachment; filename=Figure_3.png iVBORw0KGgoAAAANSUhEUgAABNwAAAIqCAIAAABwtcB5AAAAAXNSR0IArs4c 6QAAAARnQU1BAACxjwv8YQUAAAAJcEhZcwAADsMAAA7DAcdvqGQAAP+lSURB VHhe7P0J3KV3Xtd555kRRqYb2cF1RIZBRERk8VFAcFxeo4KOjoqCgjA6CI86 KPI888igjzwqDow4pNMrdHe6WTr0mt7oLJ1OZ+ssnXT2tapSqSSV1L7vddcy n+T+5s6vPteVU9e5T52t7v/39Z55vdrUfa5zn/vU9T+fbip1xfm2tra2tra2 tra2tra2tjmtRWlbW1tbW1tbW1tbW1vb3NaitK2tra2tra2tra2trW1ua1Ha 1tbW1tbW1tbW1tbWNre1KG1ra2tra2tra2tra2ub21qUtrW1tbW1tbW1tbW1 tc1tLUrb2tra2tra2tra2tra5rYWpW1tbW1tbW1tbW1tbW1zW4vStra2tra2 tra2tra2trmtRWlbW1tbW1tbW1tbW1vb3NaitK2tra2tra2tra2trW1ua1Ha 1tbW1tbW1tbW1tbWNrdd+ih95BLteGe5wEz27KHj8sEnX1yHB3YelFxgzO07 cVp0Ifz2Y8/Jh5/YLo/uOSy5wOT7Y39Mzn3e58kTneWHPXJ3bblLjp8+LnkO M9neM3vlVw/+qvzy/l+Wqw9eLYfOHpJNpzbJrx/69Yt69vSzkifattG2fadd f7tdd5vd9YCdPGXr2rlzdujkykWtnD0nebi6o8c7jllbW1tbW1vb8qxFaf9U pFABDqQiRS4w5lSk0IWgIoWKFCpS5AKTr0Vpi9K2+U5FChUpVKRQkUJFinVN RQr1Zy8VKfJwdS5StChta2tra2tb4rUo7Z+KFCrAgVSkyAXGnIoUuhBUpFCR QkWKXGDytShtUdo236lIoSKFihQqUqhIsa6pSKH+7KUiRR6uzkWKFqVtbW1t bW1LvBal/VORQgU4kIoUucCYU5FCF4KKFCpSqEiRC0y+FqUtStvmOxUpVKRQ kUJFChUp1jUVKdSfvVSkyMPVuUjRorStra2trW2J16K0fypSqAAHUpEiFxhz KlLoQlCRQkUKFSlygcnXorRFadt8pyKFihQqUqhIoSLFuqYihfqzl4oUebg6 FylalLa1tbW1tS3xWpT2T0UKFeBAKlLkAmNORQpdCCpSqEihIkUuMPlalLYo bZvvVKRQkUJFChUpVKRY11SkUH/2UpEiD1fnIsVlG6V7Osudccy92FkuMJOd OXdO7tq+X3Si9frwUzskF5h4n96yUz5z/2bZevuDcudjz4pOauQC4+6Xfsmu uEKe+8VflPywy+546g655oVr5MbDN8rKuRXJs5rCXlx5Ud504E2i87TXOw++ U247fpu8Yf8bRA+Ctxx4ixw+e1jy1Nsu7+kAw7bt9tmHbedeO71iba+xSx+l z3WWW+PIPd3ZSme5wEzG5yDR0TiQihS5wJg7sXJWNu8/Kro0Ht19WA6fWpFc YNzdeqt92ZfZD/+wnOgsbVr2aGdHO8tzWJjtPrNbHjz5oOw/s1/yxW0LubOd 5YP8yO3oLA83jZ05Y3c+YJ+4dT2On7B1bcv+o6IbVK97Xjgg5/fstxvvsBtu t8c2mz4WYBmWEi3LqTnm8h4tywVmMhUpVKTQO6GXihS5wMRTkUJFChUpVKRQ kSIXGHcqUrQoHUlFChUpVKTQg0BFChUp8tTbLu+pSKEihYoUKlLo3EHba6xF af9UpNDROJCKFLnAmFORQkUKXRoqUqhIkQuMOxUpVKRoUdqidGmXEi3LB/mR S4mW5eGmMRUpVKRQbQ6kIsW6piKFblC9VKRwkUJFChUpVKTQxwIsw1KiZTk1 x1zeo2W5wEymIoWKFHon9FKRIheYeCpSqEihIoWKFCpS5ALjTkWKFqUjqUih IoWKFHoQqEihIkWeetvlPRUpVKRQkUJFCp07aHuNtSjtn4oUOhoHUpEiFxhz KlKoSKFLQ0UKFSlygXGnIoWKFC1KW5Qu7VKiZfkgP3Ip0bI83DSmIoWKFKrN gVSkWNdUpNANqpeKFC5SqEihIoWKFPpYgGXY9s5yao65vEfLcoGZ7PjKGfnU tj2id0IvFSlygYl349bdokv3uvW5vZKHm3wqUnSi9OBb3yr5YY9cTtaynKxl eQ5z2lOnnhJ1I9518F2iExZ5uLKHTz4s9564V55feV7yxW0bbfpjLNBZOdDm bXaJtu3gcdFnfuiPIiJfXKcTFk9uNf+Rman8ubkWpf1TkUJH0UAqUuQCY05F ChUpdGnorQkVKXKBcacihYoULUpblC7tUqJl+SA/cinRsjzcNKYihYoUOhoH UpFiXVORQjeoXipS+LCEihQqUqhIoSLFMiwlWpZTc8zlPVqWC8xkKlKoSKF3 Qi8VKXKBiacihS7dS0WKPNzkU5GiRWmL0rZZTkUKnZUDqUhxiaYihT7zQ0WK fHGdTlioSKEixRTWorR/KlLoKBpIRYpcYMypSKEihS4NvTWhIkUuMO5UpFCR okVpi9KlXUq0LB/kRy4lWpaHm8ZUpFCRQkfjQCpSrGsqUugG1UtFCh+WUJFC RQoVKVSkWIalRMtyao65vEfLcoGZTEUKFSn0TuilIkUuMPFUpNCle6lIkYeb fCpStChtUdo2y6lIobNyIBUpLtFUpNBnfqhIkS+u0wkLFSlUpJjCWpT2T0UK HUUDqUiRC4w5FSlUpNClobcmVKTIBcadihQqUrQobVG6tEuJluWD/MilRMvy cNOYihQqUuhoHEhFinVNRQrdoHqpSOHDEipSqEihIoWKFMuwlGhZTs0xl/do WS4wk6lIoSKF3gm9VKTIBSaeihS6dC8VKfJwk09FihalLUrbZjkVKXRWDqQi xSWaihT6zA8VKfLFdTphoSKFihRT2KWP0nOd7ers+c7yS8vycAuzXUdPyr0v HpD7dlj9A9Krutt3/JTkH5SdPHNW9CbD1gPHZMfRk5KHq9PfowD9rRI4dtyu uso65+X5q6+2zvLDHrn80qXasbPH5P2H3y9X7b9K9He94ODZg5ILLPKOHLNP 3236e0p66S2HGS43prJ8oBu5xzrL32dVlgtMPhUp7vic6WgcSEWKAdPtER96 8kXRB/peH3/Kzt//mOkJD3TipC3DUqJlebeNuZRoWS4wk6lIoSKF3gm9VKTI BSaeihS6dC8VKfJwk09FCp2wLUpblLZNdSpS6EwZSEWKSzQVKVSkUCkgX1yn IoWKFCpSTGEtSodOn7egIoWKFGstuqY7FSnyD8pUpNCbDCpSqEiRh6tTkUJF CrUBVKTonJcuUnSWH/bI5Zcu1VSkUJFCRQoVKVSkyAUWeSpSqEih/uyltxxm uNyYyvKBbuRSomUp0bJcYPKpSKEihY7GgVSkGDDdHqEihT7Q91KRwkUKPeGB VKRYhqVEy/JuG3Mp0bJcYCZTkUJFCr0TeqlIkQtMPBUpdOleKlLk4SafihQ6 YVuUtihtm+pUpNCZMpCKFJdoKlKoSKFSQL64TkUKFSlUpJjCWpQOnT5vQUUK FSnWWnRNdypS5B+UqUihNxlUpFCRIg9XpyKFihRqA6hI0TkvXaToLD/skcsv XaqpSKEihYoUKlKoSJELLPJUpFCRQv3ZS285zHC5MZXlA93IpUTLUqJlucDk U5FCRQodjQOpSDFguj1CRQp9oO+lIoWLFHrCA6lIsQzL//l42ebO8v4ryx+D KcsXl+UCc5r++An0Tuh1y7N7JQ838U6fPSeb9h0VnbBYOXtO8nDjjg6UL/gC +87vtFOn5GBn+WNUZUc6y3NY4J08d1J0MmLTqU0XdfrcackFlms6YbFj98Ud PmozXP4YXtnWzh4fsMOd5QLT2AOPm86UgVSkWNee2HtErn3qRdENE9c+tUN2 7Tss/vQFfQu44Q7b+rxNvBalQ6fPW1CRQkWKtRZd052KFPkHZSpSqEihwxIq UuTh6lSkUJFCbQAVKVSkUJGis/ywRy6/dKmmIoWKFCpSqEihQxe5wCJPhyVU pNDtr5fecpjhcmMqy4f9kUuJlqVEy3KByacihYoUOlQGUpFiwHR7hIoUOix7 qUjhIoWe8EAqUizDUpBlKdGyvP/KUqJl+eKyXGBOU5FC74ReKlLk4SaeihQq UuiEhYoUebhxpyKFihQqUrQoLdSfvVSkyAWWazphof7spSLFDJcSLUuJlqU7 Ry4lWpYLTGMqUuhMGUhFinVNRQoVKXTDhIoUKlL40xf0LUBFChUpJl6L0qHT 5y2oSKEixVqLrulORYr8gzIVKVSk0GEJFSnycHUqUqhIoTaAihQqUqhI0Vl+ 2COXX7pUU5FCRQoVKVSk0KGLXGCRp8MSKlLo9tdLbznMcLkxleXD/silRMtS omW5wORTkUJFCh0qA6lIMWC6PUJFCh2WvVSkcJFCT3ggFSmWYSnIspRoWd5/ ZSnRsnxxWS4wp6lIoXdCLxUp8nATT0UKFSl0wkJFijzcuFORQkUKFSlalBbq z14qUuQCyzWdsFB/9lKRYoZLiZalRMvSnSOXEi3LBaYxFSl0pgykIsW6piKF ihS6YUJFChUp/OkL+hagIoWKFBOvRenQ6fMWVKRQkWKtRdd0pyJF/kGZihQq UuiwhIoUebg6FSlUpFAbQEUKFSlUpOgsP+yRyy9dqqlIoSKFihQqUujQRS6w yNNhCRUpdPvrpbccZrjcmMryYX/kUqJlKdGyXGDyqUihIoUOlYFUpBgw3R6h IoUOy14qUrhIoSc8kIoUy7AUZFlKtCzvv7KUaFm+uCwXmNNUpNA7oZeKFHm4 iacihYoUOmGhIkUebtypSKEihYoULUoL9WcvFSlygeWaTlioP3upSDHDpUTL UqJl6c6RS4mW5QLTmIoUOlMGUpFiXVORQkUK3TChIoWKFP70BX0LUJFCRYqJ d+mjtK3u1Jmzcs8L++XjW3aKDl3c9Mxu0duu10c27ZAdew7K+VvuMb0Rceu9 9p9+yVSkUJFiwPQvw8Chkyty9PQZyRcvzD5y5COif0nDQE+cekJygZlMb13o B4HTZ8+Kb1LQ22mgR56yGS4f38ryYX/M7ewsF5jGVFy4+yG7/T574mnjh3ih +l+rrXpq3xHRvyQGuh0N9KlNdv5Td5neKgPpxcEyLAVZlhIty7utLCVali8u ywXmNBUp9E7opZMRebiJpyKFihQqUqhIkYcbdypSqEihIkWL0halq9SfvVSk mOFSomUp0bJ058ilRMtygWlMRQqdKQOpSLGuqUihIoVumFCRQkUKFyn0LUBF Cn3Sw8RrUTrd6TM9VKRQkUKHLlSk0Nuul4oUKlK4SKE3IlSkUJFCRQoVKQZM RQpVEFSkyBcvzFSkUG0OpCJFLjCT6a0L/SCgIoVvUtDbaSAVKWa4fHwry4f9 MZcSLcsFpjEVF1SkUJFCRYqSo6tUpFCRQkUK3Y4GUpHCRQq9VQbSi4NlWAqy LCValndbWUq0LF9clgvMaSpS6J3QSycj8nATT0UKFSlUpFCRIg837lSkUJFC RYoWpS1KV6k/e6lIMcOlRMtSomXpzpFLiZblAtOYihQ6UwZSkWJdU5FCRQrd MKEihYoULlLoW4CKFPqkh4nXonS602d6qEihIoUOXahIobddLxUpVKRwkUJv RKhIoSKFihQqUgyYihSqIKhIkS9emKlIodocSEWKXGAm01sX+kFARQrfpKC3 00AqUsxw+fhWlg/7Yy4lWpYLTGMqLqhIoSKFihQlR1epSKEihYoUuh0NpCKF ixR6qwykFwfLudOdpS3K8rmvLF+8MKPeZNexkxd1YuWsqCSh/zNyPHfouOgE gf4wDm5/bt9FHThxWvwew2cftkc324GDpvMUf/bP2oaZihTXHrlWdHr2uuXY LZILLPJWztgtnzXd63rpLQfd1jG1pSDLckaOufRrWS4wje07aJ/8jOlFxnW3 2TPbrTP9HKAbFD6+eafo9Bxox32Pi7+FgTY/axOvRel0p8/0UJFCRQoVKVSk 0Jusl4oUKlK4SKG3HVSkUJFCxydUpBgwFSlUQdBvVOSLF2YqUuhoHEhFilxg JtNbF/pBQEUKFyn0dhpIRYoZLiValiNxzKVEy3KBaUwfhaEihYoUKlJcWKTQ YQkVKVSk0O1oIBUpXKTQW2UgvThYzqVEy1KiZSnRsnzxwqzm6Cr1Zy8VKVSk UJFCRQqdIFCRQv3ZS0UKv8egIoXaACpS6DyFihQbZipSqEih07OXihS5wCJP RQoVKXSv66W3HHRbx9SWEi3LGTnmUqJlucA0piKFihR6kaEihYoUnennAN2g oCKFTs+BVKTwtzCQihQTr0XpdKfP9FCRQkUKFSlUpNCbrJeKFCpSuEihtx1U pFCRQscnVKQYMBUpVEHQb1TkixdmKlLoaBxIRYpcYCbTWxf6QUBFChcp9HYa SEWKGS4lWpYjccylRMtygWlMH4WhIoWKFCpSXFik0GEJFSlUpNDtaCAVKVyk 0FtlIL04WM6lRMtSomUp0bJ88cKs5ugq9WcvFSlUpFCRQkUKnSBQkUL92UtF Cr/HoCKF2gAqUug8hYoUG2YqUqhIodOzl4oUucAiT0UKFSl0r+ultxx0W8fU lhItyxk55lKiZbnANKYihYoUepGhIoWKFJ3p5wDdoKAihU7PgVSk8LcwkIoU E69F6XSnz/RQkUJFChUpVKTQm6yXihQqUrhIobcdVKRQkULHJ1SkGDAVKVRB 0G9U5IsXZipS6GgcSEWKXGAm01sX+kFARQoXKfR2GkhFihkuJVqWI3HMpUTL coFpTB+FoSKFihQqUlxYpNBhCRUpVKTQ7WggFSlcpNBbZSC9OFjOpUTLUqJl KdGyfPHCrOboKvVnLxUpVKRQkUJFCp0gUJFC/dlLRQq/x6AihdoAKlLoPIWK FBtmKlKoSKHTs5eKFLnAIk9FChUpdK/rpbccdFvH1JYSLcsZOeZSomW5wDSm IoWKFHqRoSKFihSd6ecA3aCgIoVOz4FUpPC3MJCKFBOvRel09/SBY6I3x4xt u/0B8ZtsoJ/4SdPxCRUpOtNvOehzLfQt4Le37JT9J05LLjCn3X3ibtHROJCK FLnAFEZ5iP6bEegHgTuf2yvn73rQ9OYZ6LkXbYY71FmOxJHL3wNTdqyzXGCp tmX/UdHboNe1T74gtz+2+aL2Hj4q5w8eNn0sgN48UAZAH+ywnEuJlqVEy1Ki ZfnihVnN0VXqz14qUqhIoSKFihQ6d6Aihfqzl4oULlLofQi1AVSk0HkKFSk2 zFSkUJFCp2cvFSlygUWe7lpQkUJ3v156y0EZhKktJVqWU3PMpUTLcoFpTEUK nTvQiwwVKVSk6Ew/B+gGBRUpdOYOpCKFv4WBVKSYeC1KpzsVKfTmmDEVKfwm G0hFCh2fUJGiM/2Wg4oU+hagIoWKFLnAnKYihY7GgVSkyAWmMBUpVKTQDwIq UrhIoTfPQCpSzHAp0bIciSOXEi1LiZblAks1FSn0NuilIoX6s5eKFC5S6GMB 9OaBMgD6YIflXEq0LCValhItyxcvzGqOrlJ/9lKRQkUKFSlUpNC5AxUp1J+9 VKRwkULvQ6gNoCKFzlOoSLFhpiKFihQ6PXupSJELLPJ014KKFLr79dJbDsog TG0p0bKcmmMuJVqWC0xjKlLo3IFeZKhIoSJFZ/o5QDcoqEihM3cgFSn8LQyk IsXEa1E63alIoTfHjKlI4TfZQCpS6PiEihSd6bccVKTQtwAVKVSkyAXmNBUp dDQOpCJFLjCFqUihIoV+EFCRwkUKvXkGUpFihkuJluVIHLmUaFlKtCwXWKqp SKG3QS8VKdSfvVSkcJFCHwugNw+UAdAHO7Qt2/S5Dbc9t0/0PpyqW5/cLudv u9f0zux12z2m8xQqUgyYTlg8svvwRekPbiAPN6fde+Je0Vk50IeOfEhygZns zLlzopcdzxw8JudPnTa9edbt+Emb2lKiZTk1x9wTneUCs9n+Q/b0c7btBRuw Les6ZIfQJ2ocfXq7+I0xkIoUE69F6XSnIoXeLjOmIoXfZAOpSKHjEypSdKbD EvrNA30LUJFCRYpcYE5TkUJH40AqUuQCU5iKFCpS6AcBFSlcpNCbZyAVKWa4 lGhZjsSRS4mWpUTLcoGlmg5L6G3QS0UK9WcvFSlcpFCRQm8eqEihIkXbsk1F ChUp9D6cKhUpXKTQO7OXihQ6T6EixYDphIUqqJeKFHm4OU1FCp2VA6lIkQvM ZCpS6GWHihTnVaTQm2fdVKSY2lKiZTk1x1xKtCwXmM1UpFCRQkWKAduyrkN2 CH2ihooUfmMMpCLFxGtROt2pSKG3y4ypSOE32UAqUuj4hIoUnemwhH7zQN8C VKRQkSIXmNNUpNDROJCKFLnAFKYihYoU+kFARQoXKfTmGUhFihkuJVqWI3Hk UqJlKdGyXGCppsMSehv0UpFC/dlLRQoXKVSk0JsHKlKoSNG2bFORQkUKvQ+n SkUKFyn0zuylIoXOU6hIMWA6YaEK6qUiRR5uTlORQmflQCpS5AIzmYoUetmh IsV5FSn05lk3FSmmtpRoWU7NMZcSLcsFZjMVKVSkUJFiwLas65AdQp+ooSKF 3xgDqUgx8VqUTncqUujtMmMqUvhNNpCKFDo+oSJFZzosod880LcAFSlUpMgF ========== REMAINDER OF ARTICLE TRUNCATED ==========