Path: not-for-mail
From: tomyee3@gmail.com (ProkaryoticCaspaseHomolog)
Newsgroups: sci.physics.relativity
Subject: Re: Oh my God!
Date: Thu, 3 Oct 2024 02:42:05 +0000
Organization: novaBBS
Message-Id: <65d71185bba0d8d6478fade62c737da1@www.novabbs.com>
References: <Ev7wMrtKlxguxDn1RDUke8-o3Zo@jntp> <vd0ojs$3l9ep$1@dont-email.me> <llkd25FlhobU6@mid.individual.net> <ZoXepwEI4CdYzUI6TGjcOT0vC0Q@jntp> <llpubiFgheaU8@mid.individual.net> <Zq1pHnYCgAwr5qC37tYAjjYmORY@jntp> <c343b16e27e0220d0b586aadaac601bb@www.novabbs.com> <38a724f9aa7028dc455f71fda36abdb8@www.novabbs.com> <ad8212d173bdfb8447f337e7cbc13dda@novabbs.com> <1ea43eb5545f362bbcdb802e857bb126@www.novabbs.com> <ed8708d5473172c7f8fb0799eb5753a1@www.novabbs.com> <a7c57e3f538be43cae943e94dff13256@www.novabbs.com> <6867f373a4258380db55b48d0a440d90@www.novabbs.com> <f0ba713eae682022c019fb36a9df13b5@www.novabbs.com> <8c3912f32d9e1ad8f69c00cf2febffc8@www.novabbs.com>
Mime-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: multipart/mixed;boundary="------------66fe047890d427.22728256"
Injection-Info: i2pn2.org; logging-data="329046"; mail-complaints-to="usenet@i2pn2.org"; posting-account="Ooch2ht+q3xfrepY75FKkEEx2SPWDQTvfft66HacveI";
User-Agent: Rocksolid Light
X-Rslight-Posting-User: 504a4e36a1e6a0679da537f565a179f60d7acbd8
X-Rslight-Site: $2y$10$rjIsOZeuXobT5LEa9vjYUu95wmn9sjMysy9q4CTbZKzgNFEr7/uHK
X-Spam-Checker-Version: SpamAssassin 4.0.0
Bytes: 85625
Lines: 1367

This is a multi-part message in MIME format.
--------------66fe047890d427.22728256
Content-Type: text/plain; charset=utf-8
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit

On Wed, 2 Oct 2024 22:26:50 +0000, ProkaryoticCaspaseHomolog wrote:

> On Tue, 1 Oct 2024 22:18:12 +0000, gharnagel wrote:
>
>> On Tue, 1 Oct 2024 19:24:31 +0000, ProkaryoticCaspaseHomolog wrote:

>>> Our frame, the S frame, is moving.
>>
>> If it's "our" frame, then we are stationary by the first principle.
>
> ======================================================================
> No. We are NOT obligated always to make ourselves the stationary
> observer. In solving relativistic problems, we choose whichever frames
> are most natural and convenient for solving the problem. Take a look
> at https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Relativistic_Doppler_effect.

Remove the sentence period from the link
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Relativistic_Doppler_effect

> I am 74% author of this article. I did not write the section on
> "Relativistic longitudinal Doppler effect", nor did I write "Doppler
> effect on intensity", nor did I create figures 1 or 8. Everything else
> though, is my writing and my drawing (with some improvements by the
> sharp eyes of Albert Gartinger).
>
> Note how, in Figures 2, 4, 5 and 6, I compare analyses based on
> stationary versus moving observers? The preferred analysis is not
> always based on stationary observers.
> ======================================================================
--------------66fe047890d427.22728256
Content-Type: image/png;
 name=2024_10_02_21_40_03_Relativistic_Doppler_effect___Authorship.png
Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64
Content-Disposition: attachment;
 filename=2024_10_02_21_40_03_Relativistic_Doppler_effect___Authorship.png
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========== REMAINDER OF ARTICLE TRUNCATED ==========