Path: ...!news-out.netnews.com!netnews.com!s1-4.netnews.com!peer03.iad!feed-me.highwinds-media.com!peer03.ams4!peer.am4.highwinds-media.com!news.highwinds-media.com!nntp.comgw.net!i2pn.org!i2pn2.org!.POSTED!not-for-mail
From: hertz778@gmail.com (rhertz)
Newsgroups: sci.physics.relativity
Subject: Re: Relativity is a pseudoscience II. The Hafele-Keating HOAX,
Date: Tue, 24 Sep 2024 04:13:37 +0000
Organization: novaBBS
Message-ID: <f628a367d363b2fd0a311b8089a849c0@www.novabbs.com>
References: <dad338831baa98f3eb1ca50452fd9401@www.novabbs.com> <9bc3264930082f0c676a0154f4a1fd76@www.novabbs.com> <kRUHO.792253$uQe3.45331@fx13.ams4> <6472b06483c1c6be6a757c97c09a9228@www.novabbs.com>
MIME-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: multipart/mixed;boundary="------------66f23c70f38914.57556395"
Injection-Info: i2pn2.org;
	logging-data="3237133"; mail-complaints-to="usenet@i2pn2.org";
	posting-account="hWiuCAeR3KEZYJfTvV11n0qrRi6oqW/zjvEZQQGun9A";
User-Agent: Rocksolid Light
X-Rslight-Posting-User: f685b96694175b2ad43ead343ead0a9c0082fe88
X-Spam-Checker-Version: SpamAssassin 4.0.0
X-Rslight-Site: $2y$10$rdGZNFOsr099K8KHDhFp0uEi26XtokKCrcCgRzZeFSv2tVQ.Z44LK
X-Received-Bytes: 24704
Bytes: 24837
Lines: 408

This is a multi-part message in MIME format.
--------------66f23c70f38914.57556395
Content-Type: text/plain; charset=utf-8
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit

Here is another example of how Hafele MANIPULATED the data of the
"experiment". And THIS was as published.

**********************************************************************
FINAL RESULTS, AS PUBLISHED IN 1972 IN SCIENCE MAGAZINE (values in nsec)

Predicted for GR (eastward flight): +144  ± 14
Predicted for SR (eastward flight): -184  ± 18
THEORETICAL TOTAL EASTWARD FLIGHT: -40  ± 23
MEASURED TOTAL EASTWARD FLIGHT: -59  ± 10

NOTE: Starting 4 October 1971, eastward flights lasted 65 hours, with
41 accumulated hours of flight.
**********************************************************************


In this table, for eastward flights, Hafele used a total time flight of
65.42 hours, INSTEAD OF 41.23 hours. Here is the calculation of the
accumulated eastward time flight:

Hours of flight  -  Km/segment  -  Plane Avg. Speed (m/sec)  -  Segment
6.733 hr  -  5886 Km  -  874.158 m/sec  -  USNO - London
0.917 hr  -  642.74 Km  -  701.171 m/sec  -  London - Frankfurt
2.2 hr  -  1871.64 Km  -  850.745 m/sec  -  Frankfurt - Estambul
1.267 hr  -  1021.37 Km  -  806.34 m/sec  -  Estambul - Beirut
1.9 hr  -  1482.46 Km  -  780.24 m/sec  -  Beirut - Teheran
3.017 hr  -  2555.97 Km  -  847.28 m/sec  -  Teheran - New Delhi
3.55 hr  -  2912.83 Km  -  820.52 m/sec  -  New Delhi - Bangkok
2.533 hr  -  1717.18 Km  -  677.83 m/sec  -  Bangkok - Hong Kong
3.35 hr  -  2861.7 Km  -  854.24 m/sec  -  Hong Kong - Tokyo
6.633 hr  -  6200.21 Km  -  934.71 m/sec  -  Tokyo - Honolulu
4.6 hr  -  4134.87 Km  -  898.88 m/sec  -  Honolulu - Los Angeles
2.433 hr  -  1957.15 Km  -  804.31 m/sec  -  Los Angeles - Dallas
2.1 hr  -  1901.32 Km  -  905.39 m/sec  -  Dallas - Dulles
41.233 hr  -  5886 Km  -  827.37 m/sec


In the attached table, the final formula for "FLYING CLOCK DATA - RATES
RELATIVE TO U.S. NAVAL OBSERVATORY MEAN" (used on each atomic clock), is
written as:

Δτ = Δτi - (Δτf + R τ),  where τ HAS TO BE THE TOTAL FLYING TIME, NOT
THE TOTAL FLYING+WAITING TIME. That is: τ = 41.233 hr, NOT 65 hr.

Δτ clock 361 = -25 nsec, NOT THE PUBLISHED -110 nsec.
Δτ clock 408 = +20 nsec, NOT THE PUBLISHED +3 nsec.
Δτ clock 120 = -214 nsec, NOT THE PUBLISHED -52 nsec.
Δτ clock 447 = -244 nsec, NOT THE PUBLISHED -56 nsec.

And this is A SIMPLE EXAMPLE OF HOW MUCH THE PUBLISHED DATA IS FALSE,
IT'S A FRAUD.


AS I WROTE, THE HAFELE-KEATING EXPERIMENT IS AN HOAX.



And better not to REMAKE the calculations for the kinematic part on each
travel, as it's very complex to do because involves partitioning the
flight data into several segments (they used 120), in order to DISCOUNT
the flight's vectors into vertical and horizontal components ON THE
SURFACE OF AN SPHERE!!

Read something about what is involved. This method is used by Google
Maps.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Web_Mercator_projection
--------------66f23c70f38914.57556395
Content-Type: image/png;
 name=Hafele_eastward.png
Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64
Content-Disposition: attachment;
 filename=Hafele_eastward.png
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========== REMAINDER OF ARTICLE TRUNCATED ==========