Path: ...!3.eu.feeder.erje.net!feeder.erje.net!eternal-september.org!feeder3.eternal-september.org!news.eternal-september.org!.POSTED!not-for-mail
From: Ubiquitous <weberm@polaris.net>
Newsgroups: rec.arts.drwho,uk.media.tv.sf.drwho,rec.arts.sf.tv,rec.arts.tv,can.arts.sf
Subject: Doctor Who Just Replaced Captain Jack Harkness In The Most Perfect Way
Date: Sun, 09 Jun 2024 10:45:47 -0400
Organization: A noiseless patient Spider
Lines: 95
Message-ID: <v44fd2$3iaom$8@dont-email.me>
Injection-Date: Sun, 09 Jun 2024 16:49:07 +0200 (CEST)
Injection-Info: dont-email.me; posting-host="cb6bb0058e06fdf2298a39f1df7e9aef";
	logging-data="3746582"; mail-complaints-to="abuse@eternal-september.org";	posting-account="U2FsdGVkX1/qb7JxZzEdVEhGLt4WNIUev7NdIMK6q/M="
Summary: https://screenrant.com/doctor-who-captain-jack-harkness-rogue-replacement-perfect/?fbclid=IwZXh0bgNhZW0CMTEAAR0RNFavFfZecTJO2PlDkDnPKo0olNZV2KbkMzwd6INrwwuaZ9swKK9eObY_aem_AV77MS9vAy_M4HSvMy7DULD0rorVCRmForVrTxiExFa4rN4AvMm3W3VcyVVR05DNZfPl1H7AmcIxLasBalTl9uNH
Keywords: https://screenrant.com/doctor-who-captain-jack-harkness-rogue-replacement-perfect/?fbclid=IwZXh0bgNhZW0CMTEAAR0RNFavFfZecTJO2PlDkDnPKo0olNZV2KbkMzwd6INrwwuaZ9swKK9eObY_aem_AV77MS9vAy_M4HSvMy7DULD0rorVCRmForVrTxiExFa4rN4AvMm3W3VcyVVR05DNZfPl1H7AmcIxLasBalTl9uNH
Cancel-Lock: sha1:ikvZy5CxdIsr65WT0/AEA9b7Vds=
X-Newsreader: WinVN 0.99.12N (x86 32bit)
Bytes: 6926

Warning: Spoilers ahead for Doctor Who season 15, episode 6, "Rogue."

* A new character in Doctor Who Season 14 is reminiscent of Captain 
  Jack Harkness, hinting at a replacement for the iconic character.

* "Rogue" features Bridgerton -inspired elements while maintaining 
   the sci-fi essence of Doctor Who .

* The unlikely return of Jack Harkness due to allegations against John 
  Barrowman suggests he has been effectively replaced in the franchise.

Doctor Who season 14, episode 6, "Rogue," introduces a character very much 
like John Barrowman's Captain Jack Harkness, meaning Barrowman's franchise 
persona is now much less likely to come back. Debuting in Doctor Who season 
1, episode 9, "The Empty Child," Jack Harkness went on to return to the show 
several times and even became a main character in all four seasons of the 
Doctor Who spinoff show, Torchwood. The character offered a great deal to the 
franchise on the whole, but it looks as though he's been replaced by a member 
of the Doctor Who season 14 cast.

"Rogue" leans very heavily into its Bridgerton-inspired elements, but it also 
doesn't shy away from the sci-fi nature of Doctor Who. The episode's titular 
character may feel familiar to long-standing members of the show, with those 
who watched before Doctor Who's Disney era perhaps feeling a subtle bout of 
nostalgia at the figure's presence. With Jack Harkness making his first 
appearance during Russell T Davies' first spell in charge, it would make 
sense that the returning showrunner may want to recreate certain aspects.

Doctor Who Season 14's Rogue Is Very Similar To Captain Jack Harkness:
In "The Empty Child," the Ninth Doctor and Rose come into contact with 
Captain Jack Harkness during a period in Earth's history. Jack isn't native 
to the era in which he's found, he's armed with advanced weaponry, and he's 
even in disguise to blend in with the locals. All of these aspects of 
Barrowman's character also apply to Jonathon Groff's Rogue, not to mention 
both characters sporting suave American accents and being members of the 
LGBTQ+ community. However, while Jack is human, Rogue's species is currently 
unconfirmed.

"Rogue" was co-written by Kate Herron and Briony Redman. Herron was the 
showrunner for Loki season 1.

Athough "Rogue" is one of the two Doctor Who season 14 episodes not written 
by Russell T Davies, it's difficult to deny the strong possibility that 
Barrowman's character has been used as a template to create Groff's. "The 
Empty Child" was written by Steven Moffat, so there's even the connection of 
both characters first appearing in scripts that haven't been penned by 
Davies, despite being the showrunner in both instances.

Although Barrowman reprised his role as Jack when Jodie Whittaker was the 
Doctor (despite the fact he was absent for the respective runs of Matt Smith 
and Peter Capaldi), the possibility of his return in Doctor Who's new era is 
low. Allegations of inappropriate behavior on the sets of both Doctor Who and 
Torchwood may have cost him his role in the franchise. Speaking of the 
complaints against him (via Sky News), Barrowman has referred to his antics 
as "Silly behavior," and that he, "Would never do it now."

Barrowman has appeared as Captain Jack Harkness in 13 episodes of Doctor Who 
, 41 episodes of Torchwood , and has reprised the role numerous times for 
various podcasts and audio adventures.

Barrowman has appeared as Captain Jack Harkness in 13 episodes of Doctor Who, 
41 episodes of Torchwood, and has reprised the role numerous times for 
various podcasts and audio adventures. In the franchise's Disney era, his 
return perhaps seems even less likely due to the studio's family-friendly 
reputation. The ending of "Rogue" suggests that the Doctor hasn't seen the 
last of Groff's bounty hunter character, and having Jack Harkness and Rogue 
appear in the show at the same time seems awfully redundant. So, the 
introduction of Rogue would seem to be effectively drawing a line under 
Barrowman's Doctor Who tenure.

For all of Rogue's similarities to Jack Harkness, there's a much more direct 
comparison between two Doctor Who characters. With the Doctor Who 2023 
Christmas special serving as a soft reboot for the show, it was difficult to 
ignore the connection between Millie Gibson's Ruby Sunday and Billie Piper's 
Rose Tyler. Both women were 19-year-old blonde companions when they joined 
the show, and their characters both have color-based first names. There's 
also the fact that Ruby and Rose are both the first companions of new eras, 
with Piper's character leading the 2005 revival and Gibson debuting during 
Disney's reign.

Ncuti Gatwa's Doctor has been handled differently when it comes to the 
presence of his version of the characters, with some mixed results.

So, Jack and Rose have now essentially been recast by Russell T Davies, while 
leaving the original personas intact. The showrunner clearly has a certain 
group of archetypes for whom he enjoys writing, so there could be more 
replacements coming in the future to accommodate Davies' preferences. Of 
course, the Doctor has also been replaced, but that's a writing mechanic 
that's at the very heart of the show. Barrowman and Piper's younger 
counterparts now stand the chance of being as influential as their Doctor Who 
predecessors.

--
Let's go Brandon!